2005 Man Booker Prize Shortlist Predictions

Official Shortlist

On Thursday September 8th, the 2005 shortlist will be announced.

 

TurboBookSnob Shortlist Predictions

For the 2005 shortlist, the TurboBookSnob offers two prediction lists, one derived from rankings based on statistical analysis, and one based on the TurboBookSnob's admittedly biased opinions.

 

2005 Shortlist Predictions based on TurboBookSnob's Opinions

This was the first year in which the TurboBookSnob did not have a clear favourite from the start of the Booker season. The prediction list presented below is based on her gut feelings about what will happen with the 2005 shortlist.

You may be asking, "where are some of the bastions of the Booker prize?"  Certainly John Banville, J.M. Coetzee, and Kazuo Ishiguro are missing from this list.  The TurboBookSnob felt that, while Banville's prose was often gorgeous, The Sea was not as much of a coherent work as some of the other candidates on the longlist.  Coetzee's Slow Man came to an improbable conclusion and did not measure up to his best works.  She felt that Kazuo Ishiguro's new venture into science fiction with Never Let Me Go did not do justice to the subject of genetic cloning.

While The People's Act of Love did not make the cut with the statistical rankings, the TurboBookSnob believes that it is the best of the bunch this year, and hopes that it will go on to win the prize. 

Although she would like to see Hilary Mantel garner acclaim for her work, the TurboBookSnob knows that the judges quite like to include a "sleeper" in the shortlist (last year's I'll Go to Bed at Noon is an example), and with that in mind, she is including William Wall's This is the Country in her predictions.  This book was one of the pleasant surprises in this year's longlist.

The following prediction list is presented in order of the TurboBookSnob's preferences.

 

2005 Shortlist - TurboBookSnob's Picks
Novel Title/Author The TurboBookSnob's Comments
The People's Act of Love
by James Meek
This tale of a small Christian sect in Siberia in 1919 has received many accolades since it was released, and is an eloquent and daringly beautiful piece of work.

Publisher's Comments:

Siberia 1919. In the outer reaches of a country recently torn apart by civil war live a small Christian sect and its enigmatic leader, Balashov. Stationed nearby is a regiment of Czech soldiers, desperate to get home but on the losing side if the recent conflict. Uncertainty prevails. Into this isolated community trudges Samarin, an escapee from Russia's northernmost gulag. Immediately apprehended, he is brought before Captain Matula, the regiment's megalomaniac commander. But the stranger's arrival gas also caught the attention of others, including Anna, a beautiful young war widow. And when the local Shaman lies dead, suspicion and terror engulf the little town...James Meek's novel is a breathtaking contemporary fable staged against one if the most remote landscapes on earth. The remarkable cast of characters and Meek's uncanny ability to evoke the period bring to mind the work of the great Russian masters. The People's Act of Love is a magnificent piece of storytelling, an unforgettable novel and a deeply satisfying read.

 
Arthur & George
by Julian Barnes
Julian Barnes is one of Britain's greatest modern writers.  His Booker-shortlisted novel England! England! was a masterpiece of ironic wit.  Arthur & George is a bit of a departure for Barnes; it is a more traditional novel than he's written in the past, but it is beautifully executed, and this may well be Barnes' year.

Publisher's Comments:

Arthur and George grow up worlds and miles apart in late nineteenth-century Britain: Arthur in shabby-genteel Edinburgh, George in the vicarage of a small Staffordshire village. Arthur becomes a doctor, and then a writer; George a solicitor in Birmingham. Arthur is to become one of the most famous men of his age, George remains in hardworking obscurity. But as the new century begins, they are brought together by a sequence of events which made sensational headlines at the time as The Great Wyrley Outrages. George Edjali's father is Indian, his mother Scottish. When the family begins to receive vicious anonymous letters, many about their son, they put it down to racial prejudice. They appeal to the police, to no less than the Chief Constable, but to their dismay he appears to suspect George of being the letter's author. Then someone starts slashing horses and livestock. Again the police seem to suspect the shy, aloof Birmingham solicitor. He is arrested and, on the flimsiest evidence, sent to trial, found guilty and sentenced to seven years' hard labour. Arthur Conan Doyle, famous as the creator of the world's greatest detective, is mourning his first wife (having been chastely in love for ten years with the woman who was to become his second) when he hears about the Edjali case. Incensed at this obvious miscarriage of justice, he is galvanised into trying to clear George?s name. With a mixture of detailed research and vivid imagination, Julian Barnes brings to life not just this long-forgotten case, but the inner lives of these two very different men. The reader sees them both with stunning clarity, and almost inhabits them as they face the vicissitudes of their lives, whether in the dock hearing a verdict of guilty, or trying to live an honourable life while desperately in love with another woman. This is a novel in which the events of a hundred years ago constantly set off contemporary echoes, a novel about low crime and high spirituality, guilt and innocence, identity, nationality and race; about what we think, what we believe, and what we know.Julian Barnes has long been recognised as one of Britain's most remarkable writers. While those already familiar with his work will enjoy its elegance, its wit, its profound wisdom about the human condition, Arthur & George will surely find him an entirely new audience.

 
The Accidental
by Ali Smith

In Ali Smith's novel Hotel World, which was shortlisted for the Booker Prize, she displayed a truly original voice to the world.  The Accidental is her long-awaited second novel, and appears to be equally original.  Smith's writing is exceptional - vivid and intelligent.  Reading Ali Smith could never be a passive experience!

Publisher's Comments:

I was born in the year of the supersonic, the era of the multi-storey multivitamin multitonic, the highrise time of men with the technology and women who could be bionic, when jump jets were Harrier, when QE2 was Cunard,when thirty-eight feet tall the Princess Margaret stood stately in her hoverpad, the annee erotique was only thirty aircushioned minutes away and everything went at twice the speed of sound. I opened my eyes. It was all in colour. It didn't look like Kansas anymore. The students were on the barricades, the mode was maxi, the Beatles were transcendental. It was Britain. It was great.

 
Shalimar the Clown
by Salman Rushdie

Salman Rushdie has been nominated for the Booker Prize four times, and was awarded the Booker of Bookers for his masterpiece, Midnight's Children.  He was conspicuously absent from the Booker Prize in 2002, when Fury did not make the longlist.

Shalimar the Clown is an electric novel, and one worthy of Rushdie's stature.  The TurboBookSnob ventures that it is of the same caliber as Midnight's Children.  Rushdie packs more into a sentence than perhaps any other author, with the exception of Tom Wolfe in The Electric Kool-Aid Acid Test and Hunter S. Thompson in Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas .

His sentences are never ordinary; instead, they pulse and vibrate with a bright neon energy, almost as if the words could leap off the page of their own volition and surround the reader with the buzzing electric fury of thousands of bees on speed.

Publisher's Comments:

Los Angeles, 1991. Maximilian Ophuls, one of the makers of the modern world, is knifed to death in broad daylight on the doorstep of his illegitimate daughter India, slaughtered by his Kashmiri driver, a mysterious figure who calls himself Shalimar the Clown. The dead man is a World War II Resistance hero, a man of formidable intellectual ability and much erotic appeal, a former United States ambassador to India, and subsequently America's counter-terrorism chief. The murder looks at first like a political assassination but turns out to be passionately personal. This is the story of Max, his killer, and his daughter - and of a fourth character, the woman who links them, whose story explains them all. The story of a deep love gone fatally wrong, destroyed by a shallow affair, it is an epic narrative that moves from California to France, England, and above all, Kashmir. At its heart is the tale of that earthly paradise of peach orchards and honey bees, of mountains and lakes, of green-eyed women and murderous men: a ruined paradise, not so much lost as smashed. Lives are uprooted, names keep changing - nothing is permanent, yet everything is connected. Spanning the globe and darting through history, Salman Rushdie's majestic narrative captures the heart of the reader and the spirit of a troubled age.

 
Saturday
by Ian McEwan
Saturday is, without a doubt, the best novel written about terrorism, the war in Iraq, and September 11th.  The TurboBookSnob did not believe it was possible for a novelist to effectively process these events so soon.  So many others, such as Thomas Keneally and Nicholas Mosley, have come up short. 

Publisher's Comments:

Saturday, February 15, 2003. Henry Perowne is a contented man - a successful neurosurgeon, the devoted husband of Rosalind, a newspaper lawyer, and proud father of two grown-up children, one a promising poet, the other a talented blues musician. Unusually, he wakes before dawn, drawn to the window of his bedroom and filled with a growing unease. What troubles him as he looks out at the night sky is the state of the world - the impending war against Iraq, a gathering pessimism since 9/11, and a fear that his city, its openness and diversity, and his happy family life are under threat. Later, Perowne makes his way to his weekly squash game through London streets filled with hundreds of thousands of anti-war protestors. A minor car accident brings him into a confrontation with Baxter, a fidgety, aggressive, young man, on the edge of violence. To Perowne's professional eye, there appears to be something profoundly wrong with him. Towards the end of a day rich in incident and filled with Perowne's celebrations of life's pleasures - music, food, love, the exhilarations of sport and the satisfactions of exacting work - his family gathers for a reunion. But with the sudden appearance of Baxter, Perowne's earlier fears seem about to be realised. Ian McEwan's last novel, Atonement, was hailed as a masterpiece all over the world. Saturday shares its confident, graceful prose and its remarkable perceptiveness, but is perhaps even more dramatically compelling, showing how life can change in an instant, for better or for worse. It is the work of a writer at the very height of his powers.

 
This is the Country
by William Wall

This novel is an unexpected delight.  The writing is gritty, yet tender, achingly poignant at times and hilariously funny at others.  The TurboBookSnob thinks it has a real shot at making the shortlist!

Publisher's Comments:

A startling light is cast into Ireland's darker corners in the new novel by the author of The Map of Tenderness. In an Ireland far removed from the familiar images of travel brochures, a bright teenager is heading for trouble: son of a single mother who has given up, rarely at school, taking drugs, and hovering on the fringes of the city's criminal underworld. When he falls for Pat The Baker's sister his life changes irrevocably, not least because when she gets pregnant, Pat breaks his legs. But as he tries to make a new start and adjust to being a lover and father, he realises he cannot evade vengeance forever. This is the Country is a hard-hitting, tense and deeply moving novel that sets power and corruption against the fragile defences of love, friendship and family. As gritty as it is tender, as funny as it is dark, it tells a riveting tale of survival against the odds.